DEI and You.
“Dead flies putrefy the perfumer's ointment, And cause it to give off a foul odour”
Ecclesiastes
10:1 NKJV
What does a fly in the ointment have to do with anything?
This article will be about the LA fires. The conditions and circumstances which
contributed to it and the results.
I’m sure by now if you follow the news remotely, you know
about the LA fires. I’m going to look closely at the problem, which
precipitated the cause of the fire. That is DEI, or Diversity, Equity, and
Inclusion. The problem which led to the
conditions and circumstances of the fires is the focus and preoccupation with
DEI initiatives. The goals of DEI may seem nice to some, but they aim at the
heart of meritocracy. They do not consider the job's actual requirements and may not seek to cause chaos or harm, but they do most effectively. I
find it interesting that the Fire Chief and her few deputies are lesbian. This is
obviously the result of the Chief wanting to have people around her who affirm her biases and judgement, which is what DEI purported to correct, and of
course, it does not. It merely amplifies faulty values, values which have no
place in the workplace. There is no contradictory position or cause heard among
her senior staff who reflect a different set of values or goals. The other part
of this issue is that it’s surprising to me how little DEI needs to be
considered before it causes failure in the entire system. Three lesbians at the
top of the chain and the entire system collapses. The lack of effectiveness,
capability, and redundancy or available backup causes the system to collapse. The
failure to provide water promptly and accurately on target and the
entire system loses. Now, I understand that budgeting matters and that there
were decisions made that weren’t the purview of the Fire Chief, but obviously,
the Fire Chief was not able to communicate her needs and have them reflected in
the city’s budget tells me that either the system is broken or harmed in some
manner. The mayor thought that a fire wouldn’t break out and no one would know,
but we all know now.
So, what? What can we do about it? Well, for one, we can
learn why this is dangerous and broken. We can prevent these behaviours from
being present in our communities. We can ensure that training standards are
clear and universal as much as is feasible. When training standards are reduced
for a segment of the population, we can be sure that some degree of failure
will eventually happen, and we make sure that we are witnesses to it. Any reduction
in merit ruins whatever it touches, we can be assured of that. It would be nice,
perhaps, if it wasn’t so, but it is so. It is definitely and always so.
I hope that everyone will learn this lesson. I hope that
this won’t happen again, but I believe it will happen again, and again more severely.
Why? Because as people we want to believe what we believe, and we want to have our
values reflected in the world around us. The only questions are whether or not
our values are reflected around us and whether they contribute positively to
taking action and correcting the faults we work to correct, whatever that might
be. In LA, those values did not.
No comments:
Post a Comment